Posted on Tuesday 30 June 2009
Semi-Annual 2009 Bronxville Area Market Summary
The real estate market in Bronxville, and throughout Westchester, continued to be challenged through the first half of 2009. Through June 29, 2009, volume in Bronxville Village is down approximately 65% (20 transactions closed in 2008 YTD vs. 7 closed in 2009). For the entire Bronxville P.O. market, volume is down 50%. Based on the limited number of transactions, the average home sale price in Bronxville Village is down only 2.5% where as the median price in Bronxville is down 12.2% (based on per square foot numbers). Due to the limited number of transactions, we will not have an accurate picture of home price trends in Bronxville until volume increases. Other area markets have had more closed transactions than Bronxville due to their size and their performances have been mixed. As an example, volume is down 50% in Rye and the average home sale price in that market is down 14.0%. In Scarsdale, prices are down less than 6.2% and volume is only down 20%.
Interesting Trends in the first half of the year
Clearly the spring of 2009 has been a very interesting market. Following are some notable observations.
· Surprisingly, across the area markets including Scarsdale and Rye, there have been high end sales occurring (i.e. the high price for a home in Bronxville Village, Bronxville P.O./Yonkers, Scarsdale and Rye was as high or higher in 2009 than in 2008). In Bronxville Village the highest price paid for a home in 2008 was $4.15 million. In the first half of 2009 there was one closed sale for $5.0 million and there is another home that was listed for $5.3 million which is currently pending. It appears that the higher end home buyers ($2.0 million+) continue to have liquidity and are looking for value.
· The homes that have sold this year or gone under contract have generally been homes in pristine condition that represent good value. Buyers, due to the constraint of capital, are much more reluctant to take on home renovation projects that require a down payment for purchase plus additional money for a renovation.
· There are currently 40 homes (including town homes) on the market for under $2.0 million. Inventory remains high at this price level as many potential buyers in this price range have lost money in the stock market which was intended for down payments. Generally, potential buyers in this price range were more sensitive to selling their existing residence before purchasing a new one and have great job security concerns.
· The Bronxville market as well as the other Westchester markets experienced a strong increase in rentals. Potential buyers leaving Manhattan or relocating from other areas generally could not sell their primary residences and opted to rent versus buy. Potential buyers that rented in New York City but have moved to Bronxville decided to rent to better understand the market and to “test drive” the suburbs.
· Financing is clearly more difficult and obtaining financing requires a greater down payment. Deals that were done in 2007 and 2008 with 95% financing are not do-able in this market. Banks are often requiring 25%-30% down which is limiting for many buyers.
Prospects for the remainder of 2009 and 2010
· There are currently 63 total homes on the market in Bronxville which is a significant amount of inventory considering that we are in the latter part of our traditional spring selling season. Clearly, the elevated inventory levels will limit prospects for price appreciation in the latter part of 2009 and into early 2010.
· The Bronxville market is very dependant on the health of the New York economy and its job prospects. After setting new lows in the stock market in March, confidence in the area economy and the stock market has improved. We have seen a late spring increase in bidding activity and deals getting done which is encouraging. Unfortunately, it appears to have come very late and many potential buyers have decided to put off buying activity until next year. Buyers are putting off their buying decisions either due to a need to register children for schools or in order to save money for a down payment and get more clarity on their future incomes.
Conclusion
· I am always encouraged after taking potential buyers around Bronxville as they marvel at the beauty of the town and can feel the great community of Bronxville. I continue to hear great things about the reputation of the school, especially after prospects have taken a tour. When there is more confidence in the market and volume increases, buyers will continue to be attracted to Bronxville. The depressed stock market and job/income insecurity has limited buying activity but hopefully those issues will dissipate over time as the economy gets back on its feet.
· Currently, Bronxville as well as most Westchester real estate markets are experiencing a spread between buyers and sellers expectations that has resulted in few deals getting done. Hopefully, with greater clarity on the economy and the direction of home prices, the real estate market will regain its equilibrium.
